Skip to content
FrontierPicks

Watching

PRG · PROG Holdings

Conviction · Low · not more likely to lead the S&P 500 over the next three months

Business pivot Catalyst · Fintech, payments & credit

Note written ·

The last three months

Up 1.1% since the close; the S&P 500 is down 9.4% over the same sessions. Figures in the note can cover a different window.

PRG daily closes from 24 August 2026 to 20 November 2026, last $39.35, with its price line set under the older rule: a daily close above $47.40; 50-day average $33.96 on 20 November 2026. 24 August 2026: $38.93; 50-day average $42.6925 August 2026: $39.69; 50-day average $42.7226 August 2026: $39.63; 50-day average $42.7527 August 2026: $39.51; 50-day average $42.7628 August 2026: $38.96; 50-day average $42.7931 August 2026: $38.00; 50-day average $42.791 September 2026: $37.47; 50-day average $42.762 September 2026: $38.61; 50-day average $42.753 September 2026: $38.33; 50-day average $42.704 September 2026: $39.15; 50-day average $42.628 September 2026: $37.95; 50-day average $42.469 September 2026: $37.30; 50-day average $42.2910 September 2026: $37.02; 50-day average $42.1111 September 2026: $36.83; 50-day average $41.9514 September 2026: $37.25; 50-day average $41.8215 September 2026: $36.20; 50-day average $41.6816 September 2026: $35.57; 50-day average $41.5217 September 2026: $35.61; 50-day average $41.3818 September 2026: $35.35; 50-day average $41.2021 September 2026: $34.74; 50-day average $41.0222 September 2026: $34.08; 50-day average $40.8223 September 2026: $32.16; 50-day average $40.5624 September 2026: $32.42; 50-day average $40.2925 September 2026: $32.56; 50-day average $39.9928 September 2026: $31.83; 50-day average $39.7129 September 2026: $31.38; 50-day average $39.4430 September 2026: $30.81; 50-day average $39.161 October 2026: $31.04; 50-day average $38.882 October 2026: $30.89; 50-day average $38.635 October 2026: $30.79; 50-day average $38.386 October 2026: $31.17; 50-day average $38.157 October 2026: $30.15; 50-day average $37.858 October 2026: $30.79; 50-day average $37.629 October 2026: $30.37; 50-day average $37.3712 October 2026: $30.41; 50-day average $37.1113 October 2026: $30.47; 50-day average $36.8114 October 2026: $29.71; 50-day average $36.4915 October 2026: $31.00; 50-day average $36.2016 October 2026: $30.88; 50-day average $35.9519 October 2026: $30.72; 50-day average $35.7220 October 2026: $30.81; 50-day average $35.5021 October 2026: $30.54; 50-day average $35.2822 October 2026: $31.72; 50-day average $35.1023 October 2026: $30.16; 50-day average $34.8526 October 2026: $29.38; 50-day average $34.5927 October 2026: $29.51; 50-day average $34.3428 October 2026: $30.77; 50-day average $34.1329 October 2026: $33.36; 50-day average $33.9730 October 2026: $34.63; 50-day average $33.902 November 2026: $38.06; 50-day average $33.893 November 2026: $36.40; 50-day average $33.844 November 2026: $39.75; 50-day average $33.845 November 2026: $38.72; 50-day average $33.836 November 2026: $37.58; 50-day average $33.799 November 2026: $38.31; 50-day average $33.7710 November 2026: $38.29; 50-day average $33.7811 November 2026: $38.72; 50-day average $33.8012 November 2026: $37.54; 50-day average $33.7813 November 2026: $38.24; 50-day average $33.7816 November 2026: $39.47; 50-day average $33.7917 November 2026: $38.66; 50-day average $33.8018 November 2026: $40.73; 50-day average $33.8719 November 2026: $39.14; 50-day average $33.9120 November 2026: $39.35; 50-day average $33.96

Daily closes, to . Red: the note's price line under the older rule, a daily close above $47.40, set on 19 November 2026. The pale line is the 50-day average, $33.96 on .

Price line

A daily close above $47.40, the adjusted level of the 16 July 2026 52-week high, which would show the shares leading; or fourth-quarter 2026 non-GAAP diluted earnings per share above the $1.32 top of the company's guidance.

A price line, set under the rules before kill lines became business results on 20 November 2026. It stays until the note's next read replaces it; a close through it only makes the note due for a fresh read.

Research onlyNot in the portfolio.

The portfolio's record →

The business · as of

PROG Holdings offers lease-to-own financing at retail checkouts (Progressive Leasing), pay-later instalment loans (Four) and purchase programs that employees repay through payroll deduction (Purchasing Power). It earns lease, fee and finance income from consumers with limited credit. Revenue was $725.8 million in the quarter to 30 September 2026.

What is changing, and what follows · as of

What is changing now
On 28 October 2026 the company cut its 2026 outlook to revenue of $3,015–3,050 million and non-GAAP earnings per share of $4.70–4.85, citing a pressured consumer. On 2 November 2026 it began a $100 million accelerated share repurchase.
What follows for the company
Progressive Leasing's third-quarter pre-tax earnings fell 12.7% to $40.8 million, so growth now comes from Four and Purchasing Power. Free cash flow of $316 million over four quarters funds buybacks while debt is $866 million.
What follows for its customers, suppliers and competitors
Lease-to-own rival Upbound Group (UPBD) and pay-later lenders Affirm (AFRM) and Sezzle (SEZL) serve the same pressured lower-income consumer. Progressive's key retail partners, which the company does not name, depend on its lease approvals.

What the price assumes · as of

At the 18 November 2026 close (filed inputs to 28 October 2026) the shares trade at 10.5 times earnings and 2.0 times book value, with a 19.9% free-cash-flow yield and an enterprise value of $2,345 million; EV/sales and EV/EBIT are not available. Those multiples hold only if free cash flow stays near the $316 million of the four quarters to 30 September 2026 while Progressive Leasing profit stops falling.

Key figures from the filings · Industrials

Quarter to 30 September 2026, filed 28 October 2026; valuation at the 20 November 2026 close

The last six quarters

Revenue, its change on a year and gross and operating margin over the six quarters to 30 September 2026, from the company's filings with the SEC, the latest filed 28 October 2026. Where a bar or a stretch of line is missing, the filed numbers hold no figure for that quarter. Hollow marks are figures restated in the filings of 30 July 2026 and 28 October 2026.
Revenue, latest quarter ($M)
726
Revenue, change on a year (%)
+25.6
Gross margin (%)
89.6
Operating margin (%)
9.1
Free cash flow, four quarters ($M)
316
Net cash, cash less debt ($M)
−757
Price to earnings (×)
10.2
Free-cash-flow yield (%)
20.6
All filed numbers

What PROG Holdings reports to the SEC in its quarterly and annual filings. Each group states its period and filing date once; a figure dated otherwise says so. Built from the filings known on .

Results by quarter Each quarter with the day its figures were first filed, and the day of a later filing that changed them
Quarter to Revenue ($M) On a year (%) Gross margin (%) Operating margin (%)
first filed 726 +25.6 89.6 9.1
first filed 720 +22.3 89.5 9.1
first filed 743 +11.1 91.6 8.8
first filed restated 578 −4.7 100.0 9.1
first filed restated 589 −0.6 100.0 10.1
Income Quarter to 30 September 2026, filed 28 October 2026
Pre-tax income ($M) 52.3
Net income ($M) four quarters: 151 37.2
Diluted shares, change on a year (%) against the quarter to 30 September 2025 +0.2
Cash flow Four quarters to 30 September 2026, filed 28 October 2026
Operating cash flow ($M) 331
Capital spending ($M) 15.6
Free cash flow ($M) 316
Balance sheet At 30 September 2026, filed 28 October 2026
Cash and short-term investments ($M) 109
Debt ($M) long-term debt 866
Net cash, cash less debt ($M) −757
Deferred revenue ($M) at 31 December 2025, filed 18 February 2026; −8.6% on a year 37.4
Backlog, orders not yet delivered ($M) Not reported
Receivables ($M) Not reported
Inventory ($M) 3.6
Shareholders' equity ($M) 808
Valuation At the 20 November 2026 close, filed figures to 28 October 2026
Market value ($M) 1,535
Enterprise value, market value plus net debt ($M) 2,291
Enterprise value to sales (×) Not available
Enterprise value to operating income (×) Not available
Price to earnings (×) 10.2
Price to book value (×) 1.9
Free-cash-flow yield (%) 20.6

Short interest (FINRA, settled 30 October 2026, published 10 November 2026): 9.0% of shares outstanding sold short, 4.6 days of average trading to cover, +7.4% since the previous report.

Insiders' open-market trades SEC Form 4, by trade date
Window Bought Sold
90 days Not available yet Not available yet
12 months Not available yet Not available yet

Linked companies · as of

Competitors:
UPBD, AFRM, SEZL

The thesis

PROG Holdings is more likely to lag the S&P 500 over the next three months. The shares have rebounded hard on a $100 million buyback. Meanwhile, profit at the core lease-to-own business is falling and the 2026 outlook was cut on 28 October 2026. The fourth-quarter report, expected around mid-February 2027, shows whether earnings catch up with the price.

The third quarter to 30 September 2026 showed two businesses moving in opposite directions. The company's 28 October 2026 earnings release put consolidated revenue at $725.8 million, up 25.6% from a year earlier. Most of that growth came from Purchasing Power, acquired on 2 January 2026, and from the pay-later lender Four. Progressive Leasing, the largest segment, had revenue of $552.7 million, down 0.7%, and pre-tax earnings of $40.8 million, down 12.7%. The company cut its full-year range for non-GAAP diluted earnings per share to $4.70–4.85 from $4.75–5.00. It said it is "taking a more cautious view of the consumer."

The shares have since moved well ahead of the earnings. StockStory reported them down 12% at $26.06 right after the 28 October 2026 report. On 2 November 2026 the company started a $100 million accelerated share repurchase, and the shares closed at $40.73 on 18 November 2026. That rebound has already priced in much of the buyback. The likelier path is that the shares trail until the fourth-quarter figures show Progressive Leasing earnings have stopped falling.

Bullish and bearish views on PROG Holdings, Inc.

The bull case on PROG Holdings, Inc. (PRG), in brief: cash generation is large for the price. The bear case: core leasing profit is shrinking.

Bull case

  • Cash generation is large for the price. Filed figures put free cash flow at $316 million over the four quarters to 30 September 2026. At the 18 November 2026 close, that is a 19.9% free-cash-flow yield and 10.5 times earnings.
  • Buybacks are large next to the company's size. The company bought back $36.7 million of stock in the third quarter at an average of $41.47 a share. On 2 November 2026 it entered a $100 million accelerated repurchase and received about 2.59 million shares up front. The board raised the repurchase authorization to $500.0 million and extended it to 26 October 2029, according to the 28 October 2026 release.
  • Four is roughly doubling. In the third quarter of 2026, Four's gross merchandise volume (the value of goods financed) rose 102.6% to $330.4 million. Its revenue rose 113.8% to $37.2 million, and its pre-tax earnings reached $10.0 million.
  • The fourth quarter is the seasonal peak. The company guided fourth-quarter 2026 revenue to $827–862 million, against $725.8 million in the third quarter. Management called the fourth quarter Purchasing Power's seasonally strongest period.

Bear case

  • Core leasing profit is shrinking. Progressive Leasing's third-quarter 2026 pre-tax earnings fell 12.7% to $40.8 million. Its adjusted EBITDA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization) fell 12.3% to $56.5 million. Lease merchandise write-offs took 8.3% of leasing revenue.
  • The outlook came down after the quarter. On 28 October 2026 full-year revenue guidance was cut to $3,015–3,050 million from $3,025–3,100 million. Adjusted EBITDA guidance was cut to $345–355 million from $355–375 million.
  • The guidance assumes jobs hold up. The 28 October 2026 outlook assumes no meaningful rise in unemployment among the company's lower-income customers. A softer labour market would hit lease volume and write-offs together.
  • The acquisition adds debt and earns thin margins. Debt stood at $866 million at 30 September 2026, against $109 million of cash (10-Q filed 28 October 2026). Purchasing Power earned $3.0 million before tax on $131.8 million of revenue in the third quarter.
  • Analysts cut their targets after the report. On 30 October 2026 TD Cowen lowered its target to $45 from $50, and Stephens lowered its target to $49 from $55.

Price setup · as of

The shares closed at $40.73 on 18 November 2026, up from $38.66 the session before. They sit above both the 50-day moving average of $33.87 and the 200-day moving average of $35.78, as of that close. The 3-month change is 7.0%, measured from a $38.20 close on 20 August 2026.

The 52-week intraday high is $47.73, set on 16 July 2026, and the last close is 14.7% below it. The 52-week closing low is $26.18, from 18 November 2025. The shares traded near that low again after the 28 October 2026 report, so the whole climb from the low $26 area to above $40 came in under four weeks. It happened alongside the buyback news, while the earnings outlook stayed lower.

A common market view is that an accelerated repurchase supports the shares while the bank buys stock in the market to complete it. No reliable effect has been found so far for what US stocks do after one-day drops or sharp rebounds of this kind.

Catalysts ahead

  • ~4 December 2026 (est.): US employment report for November 2026. The company's 2026 guidance assumes no meaningful rise in unemployment among its customers. A higher jobless rate would weaken that assumption before the fourth-quarter report.
  • ~18 February 2027 (est.): Fourth-quarter and full-year 2026 results and 2027 outlook. This report shows whether fourth-quarter earnings land against the $1.20–1.32 non-GAAP per-share guide and whether Progressive Leasing profit has stopped falling. It is the main test of the lag call.

What it trades with · as of

The shares follow the finances of lower-income US consumers. Lease-to-own rival Upbound Group (UPBD) and pay-later lenders such as Affirm (AFRM) and Sezzle (SEZL) serve overlapping customers, so a turn in that group's credit losses tends to hit all of them at once. Monthly US unemployment data matters directly here, because the company's 2026 guidance assumes no meaningful rise in unemployment for its customer base. With $866 million of debt at 30 September 2026, the shares are also sensitive to borrowing costs. Progressive Leasing's revenue depends on a small number of key retail partners, so a change at any one of them would show up quickly in lease volume.

Caveats

  • Progressive Leasing's revenue is concentrated with several key retail partners, which the company does not name; losing one would cut lease volume. Third-quarter 2026 earnings release (Form 8-K exhibit 99.1) · as of
  • The company carried $866 million of long-term debt at 30 September 2026, after borrowing to buy Purchasing Power on 2 January 2026. Form 10-Q for the third quarter of 2026 · as of
The evidence, claim by claim (7)
  1. Third-quarter 2026 revenue was $725.8 million, up 25.6% from a year earlier; non-GAAP diluted earnings per share were $1.06, up 21.8%. Third-quarter 2026 earnings release (Form 8-K) · as of
  2. Progressive Leasing third-quarter revenue was $552.7 million, down 0.7%; its pre-tax earnings fell 12.7% to $40.8 million, and the write-off provision was 8.3% of leasing revenue. Third-quarter 2026 earnings release (Form 8-K) · as of
  3. Four's third-quarter gross merchandise volume rose 102.6% to $330.4 million, and its revenue rose 113.8% to $37.2 million. Third-quarter 2026 earnings release (Form 8-K) · as of
  4. Full-year 2026 guidance was cut to revenue of $3,015–3,050 million and non-GAAP diluted earnings per share of $4.70–4.85, from $3,025–3,100 million and $4.75–5.00. Third-quarter 2026 earnings release (Form 8-K) · as of
  5. Fourth-quarter 2026 guidance is revenue of $827–862 million and non-GAAP diluted earnings per share of $1.20–1.32. Third-quarter 2026 earnings release (Form 8-K) · as of
  6. The company entered a $100 million accelerated share repurchase and received about 2.59 million shares up front; its repurchase authorization is $500.0 million through 26 October 2029. Form 8-K filed 2 November 2026; third-quarter 2026 earnings release · as of
  7. TD Cowen cut its price target to $45 from $50, and Stephens cut its target to $49 from $55, after the third-quarter report. TD Cowen and Stephens research notes, 30 October 2026 · as of

Sources

Related · shared themes

Every buy and sale, with its reason, is published in the portfolio feed. Follow the portfolio feed → Follow @frontierpicks on X